On 29 September 2026, the news broke of the independent commission’s findings that Manchester City were guilty of 114 out of 115 chargers relating to breaches of Premier League rules, subject to appeal.
The findings sent understandable shockwaves across the football world. However, there were another set of rules which were not considered by the commission, which may also have been broken by a select number of people within Manchester City during the period covered by the charges – the SRA Principles, and the Code of Conduct for Solicitors.

The role and responsibilities of in-house solicitors
Solicitors working in-house are not the same as everyone else. They are bound by ethical obligations to which most other staff members are not. This means that solicitors working in a business have more than one master – in addition to their employer, they are also answerable to their regulator, the SRA, for their compliance with their ethical duties in everything that they do. In-house lawyers therefore cannot carry out instructions from their employers which will put them in breach of those duties, and they must escalate any such instances or any situations that they become aware of where laws may be broken, potentially even to external regulators or law enforcement. Where their escalations are ignored internally, they can be faced with no option but to resign.
The SRA Principles require solicitors to act honestly, independently and with integrity, with an overriding duty to uphold public trust in the profession (Principles 2, 3, 4 and 5). In the case of Manchester City, should the charges being put forward by the Premier League be upheld, any in-house lawyer who took part in the activities which amounted to the rule breaches could have committed acts which were in breach of these Principles. What is key to establish therefore, is how far any such legal team members knew about the real purpose and intention of these activities, and what they chose to do about it.
The struggle between acting in the best interests of your client and the Principles
According to the independent report, there was instances of sham sponsorship arrangements, a side agreement with Roberto Mancini designed to remunerate him outside of his official contract, and a company called Manchester City Football Club (Image Rights) Ltd, later renamed as Fordham Sports Image Rights Ltd (“Fordham”), which was a front for Abu Dhabi United Group Investment & Development Ltd to funnel money into the club under the guise of image rights payments. All of these were allegedly designed to avoid the Premier League rules and increase revenue for the club illegitimately.
Advising on, and taking part in the creation and setting up of these arrangements, whilst being aware of their dishonest purpose, would put any in-house lawyer at serious risk over overstepping one of the Principles. So how involved and how aware were they? No information has yet been disclosed, save that according to an article in The Times, the General Counsel of Manchester City at the time, Simon Cliff was director of Fordham until July 2013, showing some level of involvement and responsibility for that entity in that period of time.
Tom Forster KC was quoted in same article as saying “The SRA has a spectrum of sanctions, from rebuke all the way up to striking someone off. In a worst-case scenario, if a solicitor was engaged in these arrangements — formulating, approving, controlling them — and did so dishonestly, then that would be right at the top of that range.” What is important then is what information the SRA can obtain to allow them to determine the involvement and culpability of the in-house team.
The duty to act with honesty and integrity
Since the allegations came to light, the next question is to what extent the in-house legal team were involved in the club’s dealings with the Premier League and commission to answer the claims. It is completely accepted that a client is entitled to a defence and that it is for those that are bringing claims to prove them, and so a solicitor putting the Premier League to task is not a breach of the Principles. What lawyers must not do, is make or be party to any statement being made which is dishonest, and pursuant to 1.4 of the Code of Conduct they must not take or fail to take any steps or be complicit in the actions of others which are misleading.
Not just in court. To anyone.
So – should the in-house team have been aware of the arrangements put in place and their intended purpose, how far could they go in defending them without being misleading, and being accused of failing to act with honesty and integrity? The line would seem fairly clear. The Premier League report has stated that some persons who gave evidence made statements on behalf of the club that “they knew to be untrue” – whilst it would be shocking for a solicitor to be found to have been deliberately dishonest in that way, should any of the in-house team have been aware of such untruths being told they would have been duty bound to do what they could to stop it.
The wider responsibilities of in-house lawyers
Overall, it would be unlikely for every member of the legal team to have been involved in or at least aware of the intention of the club to breach the Premier League Rules. Any that were aware however, could arguably not sit on their hands. The SRAs guidance on reporting wrongdoing refers to breach of law or regulatory requirements requiring escalation to senior management, and should Premier League rules not fall into this bracket, there are still the other Principles including Principle 2 requiring the in-house team to act in a way which protects trust and confidence in the profession. Football is an institution in this country affecting many – fans, other professionals, businesses. It would be hard to argue that involvement by an in-house lawyer knowingly in the arrangements, and taking part in defending them, would not damage how the public see the profession today.
The tragic Post Office scandal has recently shone the light on in-house lawyers and the tension between supporting the business and standing tall against injustice and wrongdoing. Whilst not seeking to equate the two, given the fact that football clubs are so much more to fans and society than just businesses with shareholders, the will to act from any of the in-house team who were aware of these transgressions going on should have been great. And given the outcry and the moves by the SRA to investigate and potentially sanction those involved in Horizon, it could have been hoped that the in-house legal team would have been more alive to what they were duty bound to do.
While we wait for the outcome of the appeals process to finally close the chapter, the legal profession could again be bracing itself for yet another postmortem of how an in-house legal team, bound by ethical duties of honesty, independence and integrity, could have let it happen.